Women's Collegiate Wrestler of the Year
Lexie Basham, sophomore, Texas Wesleyan
- 2023 NAIA champion at 130, now 2x NAIA champion
- 18-0 record
- 6 pins and 4 technical falls
- Sooner Athletic Conference champion, Missouri Valley Open champion
- USA Wrestling Senior National Team member
Marissa Gallegos, redshirt junior, Colorado Mesa
- 2023 NCWWC champion at 123
- 28-0 record
- 8 pins and 16 technical falls
- NCWWC Region 5 champion, Maverick Open champion, York Open champion, Bearcat Open champion.
- Second in Bill Farrell International (Senior-level event)
Dymond Guilford, graduate student, University of the Cumberlands
- 2023 NAIA champion at 170, now 3x NAIA champion
- 21-0 record
- 3 pins and 13 technical falls
- Mid-South Conference champion
- USA Wrestling Senior National Team member
Yelena Makoyed, senior, North Central
- 2023 NCWWC champion at 170, now a 3x NCWWC champion
- 28-0 record
- 15 pins and 11 technical falls
- NCWWC Region 4 Champion, College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin Champion, Adrian Open champion, Pointer Open Champion.
- Current USA Wrestling Senior National Team member
Adaugo Nwachukwu, sophomore, Iowa Wesleyan
- 2023 NAIA champion at 136, now 2x NAIA champion
- 31-0 record
- 29 matches were either pin or tech fall
- Heart of America Conference champion
- NAIA Outstanding Wrestler of the Year
Peyton Prussin, senior, Life University
- 2023 NAIA champion at 109, now 3x NAIA champion
- 20-0 record
- 3 pins and 9 technical falls
- Mid-South Conference champion